The Pony Grill & Bar

Situated in the heart of Sheridan, Wyoming, The Pony Grill & Bar is a local gem that perfectly blends the casual, lively spirit of a classic bar with the comforting, satisfying flavors of a well-crafted restaurant. This vibrant spot welcomes you with a warm, boisterous atmosphere that’s alive with the buzz of friendly chatter, great music, and the subtle hum of TV screens showcasing the latest games — making it a favorite gathering place for both locals and visitors alike.

The menu at The Pony Grill & Bar is a celebration of diverse American bar cuisine, elevated by fresh ingredients and bold, crave-worthy flavors. Whether you’re indulging in their signature Guacamole Burger that Eric McCormick praised for its perfectly cooked patty and vibrant avocado topping, or delighting in the crisp and golden Fried Pickle Spears, every bite bursts with harmonious textures and tastes. Their Ultimate Nachos pile on melted cheeses, green chilies, black olives, and your choice of seasoned chicken or ground beef, delivering a rich combination of smoky, spicy, and cheesy goodness that keeps you coming back.

If you’re after heartier fare, the Steak Sandwich features an 8-ounce USDA choice ribeye served sizzling on a hoagie bun, topped with mushrooms and onions — a dish Jason called “glorious” and perfectly seasoned, embodying the robust Southwestern flavors this part of Wyoming embraces. The Chicken, Bacon, Mac & Queso is another standout, blending creamy queso pasta with savory grilled chicken and smoky bacon crumbles, delivering a comforting, indulgent bite with every forkful.

For lighter options, the Half Sandwich & Salad Combo or the refreshing Cobb Salad offer a pleasing balance without sacrificing flavor. And don’t overlook the Pony Chip Platter – a bright starter of freshly made tortilla chips paired with queso, guacamole, and salsa, ideal for sharing and whetting the appetite.

The Pony Grill & Bar’s dining experience extends beyond food. Their pet-friendly patio is a notable highlight, allowing guests like Mizzo Strack and family to enjoy flavorful meals alongside their furry companions, complete with attentive service that even brings water for dogs. The large enclosed deck is perfect for sunny days, combining outdoor charm with the energy of social dining.

Service throughout the restaurant is consistently praised for its friendliness and attentiveness, with staff who are knowledgeable and genuinely welcoming. William Smith’s enthusiasm perfectly captures the essence of this place—where “food is screamingly good,” and the lively, slightly loud bar atmosphere creates an unforgettable experience that makes you want to cheer alongside friends.

Whether you’re craving the comfort of a classic Patty Melt, savoring the smoky punch of the Pork Carnitas Tacos, or sharing an Appetizer Sampler with friends over local brews like their distinctive Coffee Ale, The Pony Grill & Bar invites you to dive into bold flavors served with a side of small-town warmth and hospitality. It’s an ideal stop for anyone exploring Sheridan — a place that serves up hearty, delicious food in an atmosphere that feels like home away from home.

For those visiting Sheridan or simply looking for a dynamic spot to enjoy great food and drinks, The Pony Grill & Bar offers an authentic and memorable experience that stands out in downtown’s dining scene. Just don’t expect bottomless soda refills—the cans are single-serve, but the quality of the food and ambiance more than make up for it!